Skip to content
Bellwether
LatestAll updates →
U.S. House · All Virginia races

Virginia District 5

Likely R
Compare
Tom Perriello
Democratic
9 in 100
50–50chance of winning, out of 100
John McGuire
Republican · incumbent
91 in 100

John McGuire wins in 91 of 100 simulations.

The polling average has John McGuire +4.8 across 1 poll; partisan lean, the national environment and incumbency point to John McGuire +5.6. Polls get 52% of the weight 15 days out.

Where the result could land

Every simulated outcome, grouped in 2-point steps. Projected margin McGuire +5.2; 80 in 100 fall between McGuire +10.1 and McGuire +0.2.

McGuire +30McGuire +20McGuire +10Perriello +10Perriello +20Perriello +30Tie

The candidates

John McGuireIncumbent
Republican · American politician (born 1968)

John Joseph McGuire III is an American politician, businessman, and former United States Navy SEAL serving as the U.S. representative for Virginia's 5th congressional district since 2025. Wikipedia

Raised
$2.2M
Cash on hand
$479K
Through 2026-09-30
Tom Perriello
Democratic · American attorney, diplomat, and politician (born 1974)

Thomas Stuart Price Perriello is an American attorney, diplomat, and politician. He previously served in numerous positions at the United States State Department, including special representative for the Quadrennial Diplomacy and Development Review, special envoy for the African Great Lakes, and special envoy for Sudan. Wikipedia

Raised
$3.5M
Cash on hand
$1.0M
Through 2026-09-30
Cooke Harvey
Independent

Ballot list and short bios from Wikipedia (CC BY-SA); websites from Wikidata; fundraising from the FEC (cycle-to-date, latest report).

What if this race flips? Try it in the map builder →

Polls

The polling average stands at McGuire +4.8 across 1 poll testing Tom Perriello against John McGuire.

Perriello +0.3 since Sep 28, 2026
McGuire +20McGuire +10EvenPerriello +10Perriello +20Sep 29Oct 1Oct 3Oct 5Oct 7Oct 9Oct 11Oct 13Oct 15Oct 17Oct 19

Line: weighted average after adjustments; band: 95% range of the average; dots: individual polls after adjustments.

PollsterDatesSampleResultAdjustedWeight
The Washington Post/George Mason University Schar School of Policy and GovernmentA+Sep 23–Sep 28600 LVMcGuire +5.0McGuire +4.80.70

Chance of winning over time

How this race’s odds have moved as polls and the national environment changed.

Perriello +1 over the past 3 months
020406080100Aug 1Sep 1Oct 1

Out of 100. Today: Perriello 9, McGuire 91.

What’s driving the forecast

The model blends each estimate by how much to trust it right now. Polls get 52% of the weight, 15 days out.

Polling average (after adjustments)McGuire +4.8±7.8 sampling range; effective 1 polls
Partisan lean (Cook PVI, 2026 lines) R+6.0roughly 12 points of margin vs. the nation
National environment D+9.6generic ballot + presidential approval
IncumbencyMcGuire +3.6incumbent’s side
Fundamentals estimateMcGuire +5.5±6 typical error
Expert ratings (average)—used only in the “+ Expert ratings” version
ForecastMcGuire +5.1±4.0 standard deviation, including 2.3 for movement before Election Day

All three versions

  • Polls only: Tom Perriello 19 in 100 (Likely R)
  • Polls + fundamentals: Tom Perriello 9 in 100 (Likely R)
  • Polls + fundamentals + experts: Tom Perriello 9 in 100 (Likely R)

Rules and notes

  • Incumbent renominated

House races, closest first · this is #55 of 421